by Peter Su
"Best Band to Break Up To (Post-Collegiate Division)"
If you missed Elizabeth Elmore while she was fronting Sarge during most of the '90s, her new band is where to make her acquaintance. Never exactly romantic, neither age nor custom have staled her into making music for those blear-eyed, tear-soked breakups; this music for wry grins and half-ironic (but only half-) "I hope you have a nice life" goodbyes. If anything, a decade's worth of additional experience has only sharpened her eye for literal observation and psychological nuance: Elmore balances her indie artist's eye for the telling minor detail with a therapist's eye that checks any impulse to solipsistic dramatics.
Rational, razor sharp, and -- why else bother analyzing so many failed relationships in the first person? -- lonely, she is both post-Skinner and post-Freud, full of impersonal insights inot the workings (and faults) of others (and herself) while remaining ambivalent about whether any of these insights have ever fostered a working personal relationship between two people. At the same time, she's also a detached nitpicker by nature as much by nurture, pinpointing the exact incidents demonstrating the precise reasons why people (herself included) earn her ire. As such, her personal failings -- err, quirks -- are both signs of the time and marks of her own fierce intellect and independence.
As a medium of personal expression, the Reputation illustrate the eternal tension between being loved and being free. As a band waiting for you to hear the coiled snap of their rhythms backing Elmore's sexy-thin-but-not-girlish voice, the Reputation cut the alienation of our modern age far deeper than the Strokes' retreat into cool narcissism. And since Elmore's angst is a lot less arch and arty than Nick Cave's, it's also a lot more believable. In its own way, it's as believable and real as Kurt Cobain's, only less tortured and thus more normal and easier to relate to. Outsiders not obsessed with their own alienation and likewise tuneful enough to cathc the ears of listeners with unalienated concerns of their own (like jobs) (and with Bush's economic acumen, that's a lot of potential listeners), the Reputation may well be the definitive voice for a generation of worldly urban post-collegians. Even if, so far, they're still Shelleys' unacknowledged legislators of that world.